Level-up your critiques in 3 questionsBy Hannah Baker Dear Reader, You know the critique that starts with “quick feedback” and ends 45 minutes later with five conflicting opinions and no next step? Or the one where a senior voice speaks first and the room quietly aligns, even when the data points elsewhere. Here’s a simple pattern, adapted from Visual Thinking Strategies (VTS), that pulls critiques out of taste debates and into clearer decisions. What VTS is (in 60 seconds)VTS is a facilitation pattern from the museum world that trains groups to look closely, name evidence, and consider multiple reads, without the facilitator injecting their own opinion. The basic flow: a short silent look, then three questions that move the room from observation → evidence → exploration. The same structure works beautifully on product screens, flows, and research artifacts. The 3 VTS questions (copy me)
1) What’s going on in this [screen/flow/data]? 2) What do you see that makes you say that [specific claim]? 3) What more can we find? Why it works: these prompts discipline the conversation, see first, cite evidence, then explore together, so you get high-signal input without rewriting the brief or debating taste. Curious to go deeper? I break down VTS origins, examples, and facilitation tips in this blog post. How the pattern sounds in a product critiqueFacilitator (silent look - 1:00): Facilitator (frame): Facilitator (Q1): Participant A: Facilitator (neutral paraphrase): Facilitator (Q2): Participant A: Facilitator (neutral paraphrase): Facilitator (Q3): Why this worksVTS anchors discussion in what’s observable rather than who’s speaking. The silent start gives everyone space to form an independent read before hearing others. The three questions build shared evidence; neutral paraphrasing keeps status and taste from dominating; and a clear close turns the critique into a decision ritual, not a feelings round. Use this at work: the VTS Crit Pattern (copy/paste)Purpose Roles Flow
Record owner + next step + by when. If not deciding, name what’s missing and who is responsible. Share the note with your team space. Now add facilitation, after they “get it”Once the room understands the loop, these two moves help it land:
Copy-paste lines you can use tomorrow
Tiny takeawayReplace one “What do you think?” with “What do you see that makes you say that?” this week. Watch the shift from opinion to evidence. Make VTS muscle memory. Early bird ends tomorrow, Fri, Aug 22 Enroll in a live, practice-first cohort designed for product and UX designers. You’ll work in a small group and get coached as you go. We run Sept 29–Nov 6.
Until next time! |
The Fountain Institute is an independent online school that teaches advanced UX & product skills.
Designers & Researchers Are Hurting, a Real SimCity, and the Open-Sourced Figma Rival Hey Reader, The air is crisp with the sound of the job market falling all around. Let's start with the bad news and then play with some toys. Sound good? PMs are winning, while designers and researchers are not from Lenny's Newsletter I always watch Lenny's Newsletter for the data and job market posts because they are very thorough (even if they're always a bit too U.S. focused). In his latest post, State of...
A Font that AI Can't Read, Getty Goes Bankrupt, and a New Job for Journey Maps Dear Reader, Happy Halloween! I've got you a full sack of newsletter treats for you and the product team so let's jump right into it. Here's what you need to know about the last two weeks in the tech/product/design world... A font that hides words from AI Source Eric Lu's new Decoy Font is a typeface that (for now) allows you to hide things from AI. It's an old trick called Hybrid Image where each letter has two...
Design's Obituary, the Shielding Problem, and the Future of Human Computing? Dear Reader, Halloween is around the corner, and some people are already carving R.I.P. on design's tombstone. Before you start looking for a black suit, get caught up on the last two weeks. Buckle up, there's going to be some ups and downs! Will design be the first AI casualty? Created with FLUX.1 Krea [dev] Figma Investor Gokul Rajaram posted "DESIGN: THE FIRST AI CASUALTY" on X, and it's up to 767K views. He...