Usability Is the Last Thing You Should Be Testing


Usability Is the Last Thing You Should Be Testing

by Jeff Humble


Dear Reader,

Here's a common scenario you might find yourself in:

Somebody in leadership has been pushing for an idea for a long time, and your team finally gets a chance to tackle it. You want to do this by the books, so you design three versions and run a usability test with five users.

You catch some problems early and start feeling pretty confident in your approach. The executives love the design, so everyone is happy.

The idea is finally built, but customers completely ignore it.

It never gains traction, but nobody knows why. Eventually, the leader realizes the idea is a dud and blames the team's execution for the result.

πŸ€¦πŸ½β€β™€οΈ What happened here?

You skipped the desirability test.

Usability should have been the last thing you tested.

4 Checks to "Validation"

Rather than validating an idea, you want to put an idea through 4 different validation checks. Here are they are in the most common order:

  1. Viability, a.k.a. "Should we build this?" - Generally not a design area, validated by business stakeholders
  2. Feasibility, a.k.a. "Can we build this?" - Generally not a design area, validated by tech stakeholders
  3. Desirability, a.k.a. "Will people want this?" - Potential for design, validated by users
  4. Usability, a.k.a. "Will people understand this?" - Owned by design, validated by users

Generally, you will go in that order, meaning usability is the final check and not as crucial as desirability. That might come as a shock to you if you're not aware of the whole process.

Desirability and usability are challenging because they are risks related to people, and people change. What was desirable five years ago may not necessarily be desirable today.

That's why testing is a full-time job. There are always risks related to desirability and usability. Very few designers can test for both.

Testing for desirability is a blind spot for many teams, and it's a good growth role for a senior designer.

Learn more in our four-week course on designing product experiments...only 2 essential seats left!

What methods do you have for testing desirability?

​

​

β€œwErE a FaMiLy HeRe. BrInG yOuR wHoLe SeLf To WoRk.” πŸ€¦πŸΌβ€β™‚οΈ -@tomfall

​

​Source, shared in the Guild​

​

​


COURSE: Defining UX Strategy
​
Next course: April 7-May 19, 2025​
​
Learn to design a winning strategy that aligns design with business​
​
Buy a seat ...Early Bird Sale is on until March 21st!

​

​

​

Until next week, y'all! ✌️

​

Jeff Humble
​Designer & Co-Founder
​
The Fountain Institute

​

​

The Fountain Institute

The Fountain Institute is an independent online school that teaches advanced UX & product skills.

Read more from The Fountain Institute
designing in reactive mode

Are you stuck in reactive mode? by Jeff Humble Dear Reader, Some designers spend their whole careers reacting to other people's moves. As a design manager, I remember being in this position. I had to brace myself every Monday morning for some radical change in company direction. We never knew what the new agenda would be, but we knew that it would throw our work into chaos. Sometimes, all it took was for the founder to read a single article to change the company agenda. When a competitor...

Why Your Portfolio Isn’t Working (and How to Fix It) By Hannah Baker Dear Reader, Let’s talk about a harsh truth: Your UX portfolio might be the least important thing in your job search. Yep, I said it. You spent hours making sure it showcases your best work. You structured your case studies just right. You ensured your problem statements, research insights, and solutions flowed together. And yet… hiring managers are ghosting you like a bad Hinge date. Well, the problem isn’t your...

slack growth graph dau paid users

Chasing Competitors Instead of User Needs by Jeff Humble Dear Reader, Have you ever had a CEO who was overly obsessed with beating the competition? I know I have. You may not have realized exactly how this can be toxic. So, I'd like to help you out with two case studies. Here is a tale of two companies and how they handled the competition. The first took a company-first approach while the second took a user-first approach. It goes like this... Company-First: The Rise & Fall of Google+ Google+...