How to Design in Ambiguity


Dear Reader,

Last night at our monthly meetup, a friend of the Fountain, Joshua Stehr, gave us an inspiring talk about early-stage product design work called Designing in Ambiguity.

Josh defined ambiguity as the scenario in design when you have multiple paths in front of you, and there is no single "right" path. You have to make decisions when you don't have all the answers.

I want to zoom in on 3 tools from his talk that stood out to me: Contextual Research, Proper Synthesis, and Opportunity Solution Tree

​

Contextual Research πŸ‘€

The way that Josh's team at Bunch did contextual research was by Josh's words: "Being a little bit creepy."

By that, he did a home visit where he observed people in the target persona. They went to their home and studied them using their early prototype. He watched and didn't say much.

I know many UXers dream about ethnographic field visits, but yes, it's hard to find a customer willing to let you into their home coughcoughexcusescough.

Josh's team found a quick hack by recruiting someone internally that matched their product's persona. What a great way to start doing contextual research!

Learn More: If you want to learn more about field studies, check out the section in GuidetoUXR or go super deep with this book on field studies.

​

Proper Synthesis πŸ”—

One of the biggest mistakes I see designers make in research is not doing a proper synthesis phase.

Research isn't just about gathering data. It's also about working with data. That means moving beyond the "what" into the "so what."

Josh's team interviewed me for their app back in the day, and I loved the experience. They shared their screen with me and used Miro to map my responses with post-its even while talking. They even shared my "career journey" map with me afterward. It made a nice little bonus for doing the interview.

To conduct synthesis, you want to sort Post-its with other team members until new ideas spark from the research data. Affinity Mapping with Post-its is a great way to start doing design synthesis.

Without Synthesis, the interview notes sit in Google Drive, and everybody walks away from the research drawing their conclusions. With Synthesis, you get to use your team's collective brain to explore new ideas based on the research.

Synthesis almost feels like magic. Check out this book for a deep dive into Design Synthesis.

​

Opportunity Solution Tree 🌳

Product leader Teresa Torres created an excellent way to visualize product work in her book, Continuous Discovery Habits. It's something teams everywhere are using to turn outcomes into experiments.

I love Teresa's map because she turns problems into opportunities and solutions into experiments. Josh's team used an Opportunity Solution Tree to keep track of their discovery work. I think designers could learn a lot from these reframes.

Sometimes, business people might think that "problem" work is negative, but "opportunity" work might get better reactions. Check out Teresa's book or this article to learn more about Opportunity Solution Trees.

Want to know about the rest of the talk?

Upcoming Live Courses


​Continuous UX Research
​
Learn how to run exploratory research and discover product opportunities weekly.
​February 7-28, 2022

​Designing Product Experiments
​
Learn how to design rapid product tests and start measuring customer behavior.
​March 14-April 4, 2022


Until next week, look for ways to learn about customers even when the path is ambiguous!

​

Jeff Humble
​
Designer & Co-Founder
​
The Fountain Institute

P.S. We just announced a FREE event called How to Do UX Research Weekly. Join us on January 26th!

The Fountain Institute

The Fountain Institute is an independent online school that teaches advanced UX & product skills.

Read more from The Fountain Institute

Founder of... Dear Reader, With all the hype around the new role designer/builder, it's worth looking at what that role looks like when you cut out the middle man. By that I mean, you build for yourself rather than your employer. I saved this on my Tumblr back in 2014: Think about how much harder it was to become a designer/founder in 2014 vs. 2026. That's great news, but the bad news is that the title "designer" has never been more uncertain. I'm bullish on designers in the age of AI. I'm...

Fountain Institute Vision

How the Fountain Institute Started and Where It's Going by Jeff Humble Dear Reader, In case you missed it, Hannah dropped a pretty big announcement in the last newsletter. I wanted to tell the story of how the Fountain Institute started, why we’ve never had an β€œAbout Us” page, and where I think we’re headed next. How it started The Fountain Institute started when two friends decided to grab a beer and work...then kept doing it for 7 years. There were many false starts along the way. Starting...

A goodbye and the story that goes with it By Hannah Baker Dear Reader, There's an idea I've been chasing for most of my working life, and I didn't know it. I want to tell you about it, and about something that happened a few years ago that I haven't talked about much publicly, but that belongs in this story. Some of you might already know this about me, but I used to work in education departments at museums. The thing that grabbed me in the museums was a shift that happened, away from the...